North Carolina Probate Not Too Bad? Think Again...

They other day a client came in and said that he had heard that probate in North Carolina was a "breeze."  Wrong!  While probate here is less expensive than in some states, I still counsel my clients to avoid it in most cases.  Here are 10 Reasons to Avoid Probate in North Carolina:

  1. Court fees can exceed $6,000.
  2. Accountings must be filed reporting every penny coming into and going out of the estate.
  3. Documentation of bank accounts and expenditures is required.
  4. A formal inventory of assets is required.
  5. Attorneys fees generally far exceed fees in similar non-probate estates.
  6. All filings are in the public record.
  7. Notices to creditors must be published in the local newspaper.
  8. Delay due to court rules and busy Clerks' offices.
  9. Bond may be required if not waived in the Will.
  10. Stress induced by court deadlines and requirements.

My office handles dozens of probate matters every year, so we have first hand experience with all types of estates.  I recommend avoiding probate to save time, money and aggravation.  Generally, a Living Trust is the best way to avoid probate, but there are other methods as well.  An experienced estate planning attorney to help you make the right decision about handling you estate.

Factors for Determining Undue Influence

The North Carolina Court of Appeals' recent decision in In re Will of John A. Jones, Jr.   deals with a Caveat against a Will in favor of the decedent's wife filed by the executor of the prior Will, which provided only a life estate for the wife.  The court affirmed the lower court's decision that there was no undue influence by the wife.

The Court of Appeals referenced the North Carolina Supreme Court case of In re Will of Turnage, 208 N.C. 130, 132, 179 S.E. 332, 333 (1935) in identifying seven factors that are probative on the issue of undue influence:

1. Old age and physical and mental weakness of the person executing the instrument.

2. That the person signing the paper is in the home of the beneficiary and subject to his constant association and supervision.

3. That others have little or no opportunity to see him.

4. That the instrument is different and revokes a prior instrument.

5. That it is made in favor of one with whom there are no ties of blood.

6. That it disinherits the natural objects of his bounty.

7. That the beneficiary has procured its execution.

If the person who contests the Will (the Caveator) can sufficiently prove some or all of these factors, he or she may be successful in having the Will declared invalid.

Tags: ,

Increased Court Fees for Testamentary Trusts

Another increase in North Carolina court fees:  As of August 1, 2007, testamentary trusts (those contained in a Will) which account to the clerk are subject a fee of 40 cents per $100 of receipts. That fee is entirely separate from the probate fee paid by the estate. Thus, if a Will creates 8 testamentary trusts (all of which are required to account to the clerk), each of those testamentary trusts is subject to a probate fee of up to $6,000. Apparently, this change in the law applies to all testamentary trusts, including those that have been accounting to the clerk's office for years and have been paying only a $20 annual filing fee.

To avoid this fee, the Will must provide that the Trustee of the trust is not required to file accountings with the clerk.

Fees for probate have been increasing steadily over the last few years.  All the more reason to use a living trust!

Tags:

Mediation in NC Estate and Guardianship Matters

Clerks of Court, the ex officio judges of probate and guardianship matters in North Carolina Counties, can now order mediation in those cases.  Parties to the proceedings can also request that mediation be ordered.  See this memo on the Clerk Mediation Program from the North Carolina Court System website.

While I don't get involved in many contested matters, I have seen mediation work wonders.  In many court systems, mediation is mandatory for civil proceedings.  It can save time and money for the parties and help ease the crowded court dockets.

Records and Documents Required by Survivors

Earlier this week a couple of clients contacted me asking if I had a form called and "Essential Document Locator."  I saw the term mentioned in a recent Wall Street Journal article on assisting an elderly parent in estate planning.  While I don't have the actual form (the article's author didn't respond to my request for a copy), I do have a list of questions that is helpful:

Continue Reading...

Duties of an Executor

One of the important decisions involved in preparing a will is choosing an executor. The executor, called a personal representative in some states, is in charge of the administration of the estate and has many duties and responsibilities. Some of the more important tasks include:

       

Continue Reading...
Tags:

North Carolina Court Fees Increase August 1, 2007

NC will increase some court fees, including certain estate fees, effective August 1, 2007.  The filing fee for estates goes up to $60 (from $50).  Click here for the entire memo from the Administrative Office of the Courts.

Even more reason to use a living trust!

Continue Reading...
Tags:

Play Dumb to Find a Good Lawyer?

Today I came across a question and answer column on the Raleigh News and Observer website called "Ask Holly."  The answers are written by a Holly Nicholson, a Raleigh Certified Financial Planner who also has a law degree.  The person posing the question about avoiding probate and finding a good lawyer erroneously referred to revocable trusts as "reversible" trusts.  Ms. Nicholson counseled her to begin the attorney selection process by asking the lawyer about reversible trusts, and then consider using any lawyer who nicely explains that the term is actually "revocable" trusts.

I must respectfully disagree with Ms. Nicholson's recommendation.  I believe that it is best to educate oneself about estate planning terms and techniques before attempting to choose a qualifed lawyer.  Purposely acting ignorant serves no useful purpose, is deceptive, and is not a good way to start off what should be a relationship of mutual trust.  Any attorney worth hiring will be polite and patient regardless of how much or how little a prospective client knows about estate planning.

 

IRS Rules IRA Rollover Okay Even Though Taxpayer Was Deceased

IRS regulations allow an owner of an IRA to withdraw it for purposes of transferring it to another institution provided that the funds are placed in the new institution within 60 days.  This is called a "rollover," as opposed to a trustee to trustee transfer, which is when the account funds are transferred directly from one company to another.

This is an area where many taxpayers get into trouble for not following the rules.  Generally the IRS is very strict in enforcing the rollover rules, but relief is allowed in certain situations, usually where there was no fault of the taxpayer involved.

In a recent Private Letter Ruling (PLR 200717021), the IRS ruled that a “rollover” by a surviving spouse, who was also the administratrix of the decedent’s estate, was a valid rollover within the 60-day period even thought the taxpayer was deceased at the time of the rollover.

Private Letter Rulings can only be relied upon by the requesting taxpayer, but they serve as a good indication of how the IRS would rule in similar situations.

Tags: ,

Dale Earnhardt, Jr. - a Victim of his Dad's Failure to Plan?

Yesterday Dale Earnhardt, Jr. announced that he is leaving what was his father's company, Dale Earnhardt, Inc.  (DEI), to hopefully drive for another, more competitive company.  When Dale Sr. died, he left ownership of DEI to his wife, Teresa, who is Dale Jr.'s stepmother.  Dale Jr. had been in negotiations with Teresa, hoping to acquire a 51% stake in DEI.  The failure of the negotiations led to Dale Jr.'s decision.

This appears to be the result of poor planning, or lack of planning, on Dale Sr.'s part.  I can't imagine that he would have wanted his son to be shut out of DEI.  Had Dale Sr. properly addressed succession planning for his business, he could have passed control of DEI to Dale Jr. while still providing plenty of resources for Teresa's support.

Similar results occur everyday in family businesses.  Succession planning does not have to be particularly complex or expensive, but it can save family relationships, thousands of dollars in legal fees, and even the business itself.

 

 

 

How to Avoid Probate

What is Probate?

Probate is the court process for settling the estate of a deceased person. The executor named in a Will, or a court-appointed administrator if the decedent did not leave a Will, must open an estate file with the Clerk of Superior Court in the county where the decedent was living at the time of death. 

The executor’s responsibilities include filing an inventory of the decedent’s property, sending notices to creditors, collecting and distributing funds, and filing accountings. Estates are usually settled within a year after they are opened. However, executors sometimes encounter complexities during the probate process which cause estates to remain open much longer.

The Benefits of Avoiding Probate

Probate in North Carolina has historically been fairly affordable. However, starting September 1, 2005, the fees for filing increased substantially. Prior to September 1, 2005, the filing fee included a charge of four dollars per one thousand of property listed on the estate inventory, with a cap at three thousand dollars. 

Under the new law, the cap on the four dollars per one thousand is six thousand dollars. Therefore, the filing fees of an estate with property totaling $1,000,000 would have been $3,000 before September 1, 2005. Now, the filing fees will cost the estate $4,000. Filing fees for an estate with assets totaling $1,500,000, which also would have been $3,000, are now $6,000.        

Besides the potentially sizable filing fees, probate can be time consuming and complicated, especially for an executor who has little experience with the process. Also, since all of the court documents are public records, there is no privacy in the probate process. Financial records and other personal information, such as the names of beneficiaries, may be examined by the public.   

What Property is Not Subject to Probate

There are several types of assets which are not subject to probate. For example, if a married couple owns real estate in North Carolina, the property will automatically transfer to the surviving spouse. Real estate will also automatically transfer if it is held jointly “with right of survivorship”. 

Life insurance and other accounts, such as retirement accounts or IRAs, where the holder named beneficiaries, are not subject to probate. Pay on Death (POD) or Transfer on Death (TOD) accounts are also non-probate assets, since these accounts direct a bank or brokerage company to pay a named person after the account holder’s death. A POD or TOD account differs from a traditional joint bank account because a beneficiary of a POD or TOD cannot access the account during the holder’s lifetime. 

Preparing and funding a Living Trust is another effective method to avoid the probate process and associated fees. Any assets transferred into the Trust, before a person’s death, are not probate assets. Unlike probate documents, Trusts are private instruments. Only trustees and beneficiaries need to know the contents.  

Most Living Trusts are revocable, meaning the creator, usually called the Settlor or Grantor, can amend, add to or revoke the trust completely. Living Trusts allow the Settlor to retain control over his or her assets. Typically, a Settlor is also the Trustee of the Trust and can determine how much of the income and principal should be used during the Settlor’s lifetime. Living Trusts can also provide for management of assets for beneficiaries after the Settlor’s death.              

Conclusion

If you would like to save your loved ones the time and expense of probate after your death, contact an estate planning attorney for more information on these and other options.   

Supreme Court Refuses to Hear Blackwater Suit

On February 26, 2007, the United States Supreme Court declined to hear the wrongful death case against the North Carolina private security firm Blackwater Security Consulting, LLC filed by the estates of four of its employees killed in Iraq in 2004.  The lawsuit alleges that the firm failed to provide proper equipment for the men.

While I haven't yet read any of the court pleadings, my guess is that Blackwater is concerned that it won't get a fair trial in North Carolina.

North Carolina Intestacy Calculator

"Intestacy" refers to how a person's property is distributed if he or she dies without a will.  Pennsylvania attorney Kurt Nilson has created a web-based calculator for determine how an intestate estate will be distributed under North Carolina law.

When Your Parents Die Broke

A good article on how to handle an estate of a relative of modest means...

Continue Reading...
Tags: